October 18, 2005

Supreme Court Morons

Well the Supreme Court has struck again. As happens way too often, they are absolutely and totally wrong. In this case, they have ruled that you have a Constitutional right to fuel, taxpayer money, and the labor of others. So much for freedom.

At issue here are the rights of a prisoner -- convicted of a crime by a jury of her peers and sentenced to jail time. This woman, who is so confident of her rights that she refused to allow her name to be used in the lawsuit, got pregnant. She then decided that she wanted an abortion -- but she was in prison.

The State of Missouri has decided that they do not want to pay for abortions with taxpayer money. Despite being a prisoner, where one has already violated the laws and rules of society where one loses some rights, a federal judge decided that this woman still had, somehow, a Constitutional right to an abortion.

But that's not all. This is not just about abortion. You see, the prison did not have the ability to give her an abortion. Therefore, the federal judge decided that this woman also had the right to gasoline to provide her a ride to the abortion clinic. AND she had a right to the labor of guards to provide her that transport and security on the trip.

That's just wrong in so many ways. I'd love to see a little more civil disobedience when people are ordered to provide their labor for the "rights" of others. Sorry, people, your rights do not supersede my rights -- and I won't let you take them from me while I still live.

If this ruling is applied across the board, I could demand the taxpayers buy me a printing press. I have a right to freedom of speech, right? Therefore, logically, if the taxpayers do not provide me with a printing press and a staff to run my newspaper, my right to freedom of speech is being violated. That is what this judge and the Supreme Court have ruled.

Damn, where's my country?

Posted by: Ogre at 01:06 PM | Comments (5) | Add Comment
Post contains 356 words, total size 2 kb.

1 so, you'd rather pay for a lifetime of supporting a child who would have ended up in the foster care system, rather than this? I mean, if you're going to raise hell for some moral reason, that's one thing, but this argument doesn't even make any sense. If you're concerned about your tax dollars, be glad the judge decided this way, rather than the opposite - you get off cheaper this way.

Posted by: Erin Monahan at October 18, 2005 10:23 PM (vtVgw)

2 Erin, I'd just like to point out that your comment does not touch on the issue Ogre has posted about. The point is that the courts are once again "legislating from the bench" by putting words in the Constitution's "mouth" that are not part of the Constitution and by my read, each of these tamperings with what are and aren't American rights bring us closer and closer to socialism, the antithesis of our extremely successful form of government. Every time this happens, a legal precedent is set.

Posted by: Seth at October 18, 2005 11:16 PM (+YZMv)

3 Yes, it's not about the money spent, it about the sources of that money -- the judges have determined that other people somehow have a right not only to other's money, but to their labor as well.

Posted by: Ogre at October 19, 2005 05:57 AM (iJFc9)

4 Erin, for me, yes I would rather see a life saved and supported than destroyed and aborted. This argument you use-- WOULD YOU RATHER PAY FOR A LIFETIME of SUPPORTING A CHILD....is old and lame. It's the expected rhetoric from liberals who have brainwashed people like you into believing this to be fact! There are other options besides abortion. And the government should not have to pay for this. THAT government is me, you (I'm assuming you work and pay taxes) and everyone else who works for a living.

Posted by: Raven at October 19, 2005 09:19 AM (3kz8d)

5 And in a free country, that wouldn't be an issue because *I* wouldn't be forced to pay for someone else's bad decisions -- THEY would.

Posted by: Ogre at October 19, 2005 09:56 AM (/k+l4)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
18kb generated in CPU 0.0112, elapsed 0.0806 seconds.
88 queries taking 0.0746 seconds, 194 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.